Seeing a fast-moving brown or black insect in your home can immediately make you think you have found a cockroach. However, several insects share some of the same colors, sizes and behaviors as household roaches.
Beetles, crickets, true water bugs and even bed bugs may be mistaken for cockroaches at first glance. Looking closely at the insect’s body shape, antennae, wings, legs and behavior can help you tell the difference.
Before comparing common look-alikes, it helps to understand what an actual cockroach looks like.
The exact appearance depends on the species and life stage, but most household cockroaches share several characteristics like having six legs, two long thin antennae, wings if they are adults, and a shield-like section behind the head.
Cockroaches are also fast runners. They usually run toward a dark hiding place when exposed to light or activity.
Common household species can vary significantly in size. German cockroaches are relatively small and light brown, while American and Oriental cockroaches are much larger. The Combat® brand guide to small roaches versus large roaches can help you compare common species.
Little could be worse than being accused of being a cockroach. There are numerous bugs that people confuse with cockroaches. If you’ve ever had a June bug flying directly into your face, you might not care whether or not it was a cockroach. But June bugs are just big beetles and, providing they don’t bounce off one of your eyeballs, they pose little threat to humans. While cockroaches live on garbage, rotting animals, and feces flowing through sewers, June bugs are leaf-eating vegetarians. They can damage plants when they emerge in large numbers, but June bugs are not cockroachian disease vectors.
The June bug’s cousin, the ground beetle also bears passing resemblance to the roach. Some of the 2,000 species of ground beetle in North America are sometimes confused with oriental roaches because they are both shiny and very dark in color. However, beetles have hardened front wings while roaches have leathery wings or no wings at all. Like the cockroach, the ground beetle comes out at night to feed and will run away quickly when exposed. However, if you see a ground beetle in your yard, do not kill it. They eat pests such as snails and root maggots which can wreak havoc on your garden and flowerbeds. If a beetle wanders into your house through a crack under the door or around the window, simply return it to the wild.
The cricket is another bug often misidentified as a cockroach. Crickets like cockroaches, can be brown or black and both species have antennae as long as their creepy little bodies. Like all insects, crickets have six legs. And the front wings that cover their abdomens are similar to those found on cockroaches. But other than a vaguely similar resemblance, crickets are nothing like roaches. They eat plant material and live outdoors in grassy fields and lawns. And while cockroaches leave trails of allergenic saliva and feces while exploring your house, crickets are beneficial to the environment. They provide a chirping food source to birds, reptiles, and mammals. If you see a cricket in your house, it got there by accident. You can try the catch and release method with a glass and a drink coaster. Then enjoy the sounds of the crickets singing on a summer night.
True water bugs are sometimes confused with cockroaches because both can be large, dark and somewhat flattened. The confusion becomes greater because people in some regions use “water bug” as an informal name for Oriental or American cockroaches.
Cockroaches have much longer antennae and legs adapted for running rather than swimming. Household roaches are generally found around food, plumbing, drains, basements and protected indoor spaces.
True water bugs can bite defensively if handled, so avoid picking one up with your bare hands.
Adult bed bugs do not closely resemble adult cockroaches, but they may be confused with young cockroach nymphs. Both can be small, brown or reddish-brown, and wingless. Location can provide another clue. Bed bugs typically gather near places where people sleep or rest, including mattress seams, bed frames, headboards and upholstered furniture. Cockroach nymphs are more commonly associated with kitchens, bathrooms, appliances and areas near food or water.
However, location alone is not enough to make a positive identification. Learn more about the changing appearance of cockroaches in our guide to identifying roaches at every life stage.
Earwigs have long brown bodies and antennae, which may cause them to look somewhat like small cockroaches when seen quickly.
The easiest distinguishing feature is the pair of noticeable pincers at the rear of an earwig’s body. Cockroaches have much smaller rear appendages, but they do not have the large curved forceps associated with earwigs.
Winged termites, also called swarmers or alates, may be confused with winged cockroaches, especially when several insects suddenly appear indoors.
Cockroaches have long, thin antennae and a flatter, more oval body. Their front and rear wings also differ in structure, and the head may be partially covered by the shield-like pronotum.
Discarded piles of equal-length wings near windows, doors or wooden structures may indicate termite activity rather than cockroaches. Because termite identification and treatment require a different approach, consider having the insect professionally identified.
If you identify the insect as a cockroach, inspect the surrounding area for droppings, egg cases, shed skins, and additional activity. There are usually signs that there are cockroaches nearby. If you do find them, you can use roach killing products like Combat® to help kill them at the source.